Health Economic Methodology Guides
Welcome to our methodology hub. Guided by internationally recognized standards and lessons from teaching and global research leadership, these practical guides demystify the science and art of health economic evaluation for diverse audiences.
Types of Economic Evaluation
There are several ways to compare costs and effects in economic evaluations. The table on the right outlines the major types of economic evaluation methods.
The first type of evaluation assesses only costs, without considering outcomes. The next method is Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (CEA), which is the focus of this lecture. In CEA, costs are measured in monetary units, while effects are assessed in natural units, such as mortality, morbidity, cases, or patient visits.
Some health economists have attempted to distinguish between CEA and Cost-Utility Analysis (CUA), primarily reflecting preferences within the UK, where researchers often use Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) as the measure of effectiveness. In contrast, measures like QALYs and Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) represent societal preferences. In CUA, outcomes are specifically measured in QALYs. Regardless, CUAs are essentially the same as CEAs when outcomes are measured in either DALYs or QALYs. For our purposes, this distinction is not particularly significant.
Lastly, we have Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA), where both costs and outcomes are measured in monetary terms. In a CBA, the outcomes are also expressed in monetary value, allowing for a direct comparison of costs and benefits.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Cost-effectiveness analysis is a method used to compare the relative costs and outcomes/effects of two or more alternative actions. Unlike CBA, CEA does not require that outcomes be expressed in monetary terms. Instead, it typically measures results in natural units, such as lives saved, cases prevented, or quality-adjusted life years (QALY) gained. The result is a ratio, such as “cost per life year saved” or “cost per case prevented,” which helps determine which option delivers the desired outcome for the lowest cost. CEA is especially useful in fields like healthcare or public policy where quantifying benefits in monetary terms can be difficult or ethically inappropriate. CEA helps decision-makers identify the most efficient option, but does not directly answer whether the benefit justifies the cost—that judgment requires additional value-based or policy considerations
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Cost-benefit analysis is a systematic process used to evaluate the economic worthiness of investments, projects, or policy decisions by comparing their expected costs and benefits. All anticipated costs—both direct (like construction or labor) and indirect (like opportunity or intangible costs)—are summed and weighed against all benefits, which can be tangible (such as revenue or cost savings) or intangible (such as improved employee morale or customer satisfaction). Benefits and costs are typically expressed in monetary terms, allowing for a clear financial comparison. The key question answered by a CBA is: Do the projected benefits outweigh the projected costs? If so, the project or decision is generally considered worth pursuing. CBA also incorporates concepts like opportunity cost and may use calculations such as net present value (NPV), return on investment (ROI), and the benefit-cost ratio (BCR)
Economic Evaluation Course Series: Uncover the Secrets Behind Health Program Funding Decisions
Have you ever found yourself questioning how policymakers determine which health programs deserve financial support? The decision-making process can often seem complex and opaque. That’s why we invite you to explore our engaging non-audio introduction to Economic Evaluation, expertly led by Dagna Constenla. In this comprehensive overview, you will gain valuable insights into the fundamental concepts that drive health policy decisions. Dagna will guide you through the essential principles of economic evaluation, helping you understand how data influences the allocation of resources to various health initiatives. Why is this important? Because health program funding impacts millions of lives. By understanding the criteria that shape these decisions, you can become an informed advocate for effective health solutions in your community. Whether you're a health professional, a student, or simply an interested citizen, this introduction provides the tools you need to grasp the nuances of economic evaluations. Join us on this informative journey to empower yourself and make a difference. Don’t miss this opportunity to learn from an expert and expand your knowledge on how economic evaluation plays a critical role in shaping the health landscape. Dive in now and discover the power of informed decision-making in health policy!
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Explained: A Beginner's Guide for Public Health
Unlock the power of economic evaluation in public health decision-making! This introductory module explores cost-effectiveness analysis and its real-world applications.
Cost-Utility Analysis Explained: US Guidelines & Key Concepts - Clear, uses the full term, and promises a practical overview
Dive into the world of cost-utility analysis (CUA)! This module provides a comprehensive introduction to CUA, a critical tool for evaluating healthcare interventions.
US Panel Guidelines on Cost-Effectiveness: A Deep Dive (Healthcare)
Unlock a comprehensive understanding of the US Panel guidelines on cost-effectiveness analysis in healthcare! This in-depth module provides a thorough overview of the recommendations and best practices.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: What's Changed Since the 1996 US Guidelines?
Explore how cost-effectiveness analysis has evolved since the 1996 US Guidelines! This module dives into the key changes, new methods, and the importance of international collaboration.
Weighted Criteria for Cost-Effectiveness: Improving Analysis or Overcomplicating?
Explore the complexities of weighted criteria in cost-effectiveness analysis! This module examines the rationale behind weighting, using the Chiou et al. (2003) study as a key example.
International Guidelines to Cost-Effectiveness: Why Now?
Dive into the international world of cost-effectiveness! This module dives into why computer technology has helped push this important aspect to the forefront.
Cost-Effectiveness Basics: Dominance & Incremental Thinking Explained!
We break down the core concepts of strong dominance and incremental thinking, providing clear explanations and practical examples.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Key Concepts
This resource explains core concepts in cost-effectiveness analysis: strong dominance (identifying cheaper, better options), incremental thinking (focusing on extra costs/outcomes), ICERs (calculating cost per added benefit), and weak dominance (handling multiple options). Learn how to analyze and interpret cost-effectiveness in healthcare.
Sensitivity Analysis: A Deep Dive into How the decision is affected by any one aspect
Get a grasp on how sensitivity analysis changes the likelihood of your conclusion in cost-effectiveness with this essential presentation! We break down what sensitivity and all the moving parts are here.
Understanding Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Dominance and Incremental Thinking
Is your organization trying to make the most of its healthcare investments? This module dives into the core concepts of cost-effectiveness analysis, providing you with the knowledge to make informed decisions. Learn to identify interventions that offer superior value by exploring strong dominance, incremental thinking, incremental cost-effectiveness ratios, and weak dominance.
Perspectives in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Choosing the Right Lens
Whose costs and benefits matter? This module explores key perspectives in cost-effectiveness analysis – societal, government, healthcare system, private payer, provider, and individual. Learn how to select the appropriate perspective to align with your research question and decision-making goals, and understand the implications of each choice.
Unlock Accurate Healthcare Costs: Your Guide to a Complete Cost Inventory
Are you struggling to accurately measure costs in your healthcare interventions? A complete cost inventory is the foundation of any robust cost-effectiveness analysis.
Micro-Costing in Healthcare: A Detailed Guide
What is micro-costing, and when is it the right approach for healthcare cost measurement? This presentation explores the nuances of micro-costing, including gathering participant data, accounting for foregone wages, and using data triangulation to improve accuracy. Learn how to apply micro-costing to new services, variations among providers, and research.
Cost Measurement in Health Economics: A Visual Impairment Case Study
How do health economists measure the costs of healthcare interventions? This module delves into the complexities of cost measurement, using visual impairment as a real-world example. We'll explore different costing methods, including micro-costing and surveys, and discuss how to interpret cost data in research. Learn valuable techniques to apply to your own economic evaluations!
Understanding Time Horizons in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
This lecture focuses on the concept of time horizons in cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA). It defines what a time horizon is, its relevance to evaluating costs and outcomes in various healthcare interventions, and emphasizes the importance of understanding the timeframes for different populations and conditions. Through specific examples such as influenza vaccination, dysfunctional uterine bleeding treatment, HPV interventions, glaucoma treatment, and intergenerational programs, the lecture illustrates how differing time horizons can significantly impact cost-effectiveness outcomes.
Understanding Inflation in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
This lecture addresses the critical topic of inflation in the context of cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA). It outlines why analysts must adjust for inflation and why readers should ensure that such adjustments are made when evaluating studies. Key areas of focus include the difference between general inflation and medical care price inflation, the variations in inflation across countries, and the importance of currency conversion in international analyses. The lecture aims to equip analysts and readers with the understanding needed to interpret costs accurately over time and across different economies.
Understanding Discounting in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
This lecture delves into the concept of discounting within the context of cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA). It begins by explaining the mechanics of discounting and its relation to present value, making analogies to everyday financial situations such as loans and retirement accounts. The lecture addresses the debate over whether to apply one discount rate for both costs and effects or to have separate rates for each. Additionally, it explores how discounting interacts with inflation adjustments and time horizons, providing a comprehensive understanding of how these elements combine to affect the evaluation of costs in healthcare.
When QALYs are Right: A Guide to Choosing Outcome Measures
Learn when and why to use Quality-Adjusted Life-Years (QALYs) in cost-effectiveness analysis. This module covers definitions and appropriate applications, including when quality of life is a key consideration.
QALYs Explained: Understanding Quality-Adjusted Life Years
In this presentation, you'll get a clear introduction to Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs). We'll break down what QALYs are and why they're used in healthcare decision-making, how health utility is measured and visualized using graphs (death = 0, perfect health = 1). You will also learn about the concept of "area under the curve" and how it relates to QALY calculation and the different health scenarios that can result in the same QALY score (e.g., living with blindness vs. shorter life in perfect health), and how QALYs help compare different health outcomes and treatments.
When is it Inappropriate to Use QALYs?
This module discusses situations when it is not appropriate to use QALYs, including when only intermediate effectiveness data can be obtained, when effectiveness data show that alternatives are equally effective, when QOL is essential but can be captured with a single variable in easily understandable units, and when the extra cost of obtaining utility data is prohibitive.
How to Calculate QALYs: Measuring Health Utility Directly
This module will cover the calculation of Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs). It will specifically focus on measuring health utility directly, explaining methods and considerations for obtaining these measurements. The module may include graphical representations of QALYs and explore how to construct these graphs.
Calculating QALYs: Exploring Direct Measurement Approaches
This module delves into direct methods for assessing health utility, a crucial component of QALY calculations. It examines various techniques, including visual analog scales, time trade-off exercises, and standard gamble scenarios, outlining how these methods are used to quantify individual preferences for different health states.
Calculating QALYs: Standard Instruments Explored
Learn about commonly used instruments for QALY calculation, including EuroQOL, QWB, HUI, and SF-6D. Understand their strengths and weaknesses.
What are DALYs? Disability Adjusted Life Years Explained
Ever wondered how we measure the burden of disease across populations? This presentation explores Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs), a crucial metric used in public health and epidemiology. DALYs help us understand the impact of both mortality and morbidity, allowing for better resource allocation and intervention strategies.
Understanding DALYs: Person Trade-off Exercise & Disability Weights (Global Health)
In this presentation, we break down the Person Trade-off Exercise used in calculating Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs). Explore how health utilities and trade-offs, like the value of curing blindness versus living in perfect health, are used to assess disability weights. Learn about the methodology behind DALY calculations, including age weighting, discounting, and how DALYs are used in global health comparisons. Understand the significance of disability weights for conditions like vitiligo, erectile dysfunction, deafness, Down syndrome, and more. Get insights from the Global Burden of Disease project.
QALYs in Practice: Analyzing Studies of Uterine Bleeding Treatments
Explore real-world studies of treatments for heavy uterine bleeding, examining how QALYs can be used to compare effectiveness and inform treatment decisions.
Cost-Outcome Analysis EXPLAINED! (Cost-Benefit, Cost-Effectiveness, & More)
Confused by cost-benefit, cost-effectiveness, and other economic analyses? This presentation provides a clear and simple breakdown of the major types of cost-outcome analysis. Learn how these methods are used to evaluate healthcare interventions and make informed decisions.
Cost-Outcome Analyses and Multiple Outcomes Issues: Additional Concepts in Health Economics
Deepen your understanding of cost-outcome analysis by learning about various analysis types (cost-minimization, cost-effectiveness, etc.) and the challenges of interpreting multiple outcomes.
Applying Cost-Effectiveness Analyses: Hypothetical Scenarios
Work through real-world applications of cost-effectiveness analysis. Examine hypothetical examples in breastfeeding support, behavioral interventions, and senior volunteer programs.
Child Behavior Problems: Literature Examples Using Economic Evaluation to Evaluate Interverventions
Learn how to navigate the challenges of applying cost-effectiveness analysis to complex interventions for child behavior, including addressing multiple outcomes, measuring long-term effects, and accounting for different perspectives.
Making Informed Decisions: Economic Evaluations of Schizophrenia Treatment
This module provides practical insights into evaluating the economic impact of different schizophrenia treatments, using real-world examples from the medical literature.
Cost-Effectiveness in Policy: Considerations and Challenges
A look at the use of cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) in policy decisions. This module discusses what economics provides (and doesn't provide) to the process, potential applications of economic analysis, and the reasons why CEA may not always be used.
Neumann's Perspective on Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (CEA) in Decision Making
Explore why cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) is not necessarily the key factor in healthcare decisions. Based on the perspective of Neumann, this module dives into issues like politics, trust, and methods that affect the use of CEA in policy.
Is the US Ready for Cost-Effectiveness in Healthcare?
Explore the ongoing debate: Is the United States any closer to embracing cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) in healthcare policy? This module examines the current landscape and challenges that impact the adoption of CEA.
Global Health Decisions: How Countries Use Cost-Effectiveness
Ever wonder how other countries decide which health technologies to cover? This module explores real-world examples from around the globe, highlighting the role of cost-effectiveness in international healthcare.
Disclaimer: This course, Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for Public Health: A Beginner's Guide, was developed by Dagna Constenla during her tenure as an Associate Research Professor in the Department of International Health at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. The content reflects the state of knowledge and best practices as of 2017.
This course is now offered independently by Climawahealth and is separate from Johns Hopkins University. The views, opinions, and methodologies presented in this course are solely those of the instructor, Dagna Constenla, and do not necessarily represent the views or policies of Johns Hopkins University. Johns Hopkins University does not endorse or assume any responsibility for the current content, delivery, or any outcomes associated with this independently offered course.
The initial development of this course benefited from the use of certain resources (e.g., software, equipment) available at Johns Hopkins University. Copyright © 2017 Johns Hopkins University. Certain materials within this course may be subject to the copyright of Johns Hopkins University and are used with permission. Any further use or reproduction of these materials requires authorization from Johns Hopkins University.
While the foundational principles remain relevant, please note that the field of economic evaluation is continually evolving. Climawahealth strives to provide up-to-date and accurate information, but we encourage learners to consult current research and best practices in conjunction with this course.